Givebutter Alternatives
Six fundraising platforms and donor CRMs that replace Givebutter, compared on who pays: you, your donors, or nobody.
The best Givebutter alternative depends on what bothers you: the tip prompt your donors see, the 3% fee when you switch tips off, or a CRM that stops short. To keep fundraising free with every feature included, Zeffy is the closest swap. For forms with low, published platform fees and no tip prompt, Donorbox; for a real donor CRM with a public starting price, Neon CRM. RallyUp, Little Green Light and Bloomerang cover auctions and raffles, a cheap donor database and a full giving platform. Below, what one $100 gift really costs on each, and the fee traps we found while comparing them.
The ranking is editorial: a sponsored placement is always flagged on its card, and no affiliate link changes a score.
Why people are leaving Givebutter
Givebutter is a fundraising platform with a free donor CRM attached: donation forms, campaign pages, events, auctions and a mobile app, with unlimited users and contacts on the free plan. It is free because donors are asked to tip the platform at checkout. Most nonprofits that leave do not leave the forms; they leave the money model around them, or a CRM that stops at the upgrade. The reasons below come from Givebutter's own pricing page, its community board and public reviews written by donors and nonprofit admins.
Donors see a tip they did not expect
Switching tips off costs 3% plus processing
The useful CRM features sit behind Plus
Plus is priced by contacts, and contacts grow by themselves
Auctions charged to a saved card pay fees even with tips on
Some teams need more than a fundraising CRM
Zeffy
Zeffy is the alternative that goes one step further than Givebutter on price. Both are funded by optional contributions that donors leave at checkout, but Zeffy has one plan, at $0, and every feature sits in it. More importantly, Zeffy covers credit card and transaction fees itself: you never pay a platform fee, a processing fee or a payout fee, and the nonprofit keeps 100% of what donors give, whether they tip or not. On Givebutter, that outcome depends on the setting you pick; on Zeffy, there is no setting.
The toolbox is wide for a free product: donation forms and pages, event ticketing, raffles, auctions, memberships, peer-to-peer campaigns, online stores, a Tap to Pay app for in-person payments, a donor CRM, newsletters and emails, and Donor Mail for printed thank-you letters and appeals. Donors pay by card, Apple Pay, Google Pay or bank transfer. On average, 2 of 3 donors leave a tip, which Zeffy says covers its costs.
What you give up is control over the tip model itself. If the reason you are leaving Givebutter is that donors dislike a contribution request at checkout, Zeffy asks too; Donorbox, which charges you a fee instead, is the cleaner option. And there is no paid tier: if you need premium support or advanced CRM automation, you will pair Zeffy with a CRM such as Neon CRM or Little Green Light, or compare our nonprofit CRM picks.
- Zeffy covers card and transaction fees itself
- Every feature in one $0 plan
- Raffles, auctions, stores and memberships included
- ✓The nonprofit keeps 100% of each gift, tip or not
- ✓No paid upgrade to budget for
- ✓Printed Donor Mail and email newsletters in the same tool
- ✗Donors still see a contribution request at checkout
- ✗One plan only: no premium support tier to buy
- ✗CRM is lighter than a dedicated donor database
| Criterion | Zeffy | Givebutter |
|---|---|---|
| Cost on a $100 card gift | $0 to the nonprofit | $0 with tips on, $6.20 with tips off |
| Who funds the platform | Optional donor contributions | Optional donor tips, or a 3% fee |
| Paid tier | None | Plus, from $29/month billed annually |
| Processing fees | Covered by Zeffy | Covered with tips on, 2.9% + 30¢ off |
The pick when every dollar must reach the cause and your donors accept a tip prompt. If the tip prompt is the problem, choose Donorbox.
Donorbox
Donorbox works the other way round from Givebutter and Zeffy: no tip request to the donor, a platform fee charged to you. The Standard plan has no setup fee and no monthly fee; each donation carries a platform fee of 2.95% on donation forms, fundraising pages, QuickDonate and organization crowdfunding pages, and 3.95% on event ticketing, memberships and supporter peer-to-peer pages, plus the payment processor's own fee. You can let donors cover the fees at checkout, which keeps the gift whole without a tip line.
Standard includes 5 team members, unlimited donation forms, donation pages, crowdfunding and peer-to-peer campaigns, event ticketing, memberships and a branded donor portal. The Pro plan, at $150 a month, lowers the platform fee to 1.75% on forms and 2% on events and memberships, adds 10 team members, Zapier and API access, crypto and stock donations, and advanced form customizations. Premium, priced on a demo, goes to 1.6% and 30 team members, plus a choice of extras such as 24/7 priority support and migration of recurring donors.
Donorbox CRM, the donor management layer, is sold through sales, and add-ons such as Text-to-Give ($19 a month) or the Live Kiosk app ($80 a month or $820 a year for the first device on Standard and Pro) are billed on top. Do the math before upgrading: Pro only pays for itself once you raise about $12,500 a month through forms.
- No tip request shown to donors
- Platform fee published per feature
- Pro and Premium lower the fee to 1.75% and 1.6%
- ✓Donors can cover all fees at checkout
- ✓Crypto and stock gifts on Pro
- ✓Zapier and API access on Pro
- ✗2.95% platform fee on every Standard gift
- ✗CRM sold through a sales call
- ✗Kiosk, texting and migration are paid add-ons
| Criterion | Donorbox | Givebutter |
|---|---|---|
| Cost on a $100 card gift | $2.95 platform fee + processing | $0 with tips on, $6.20 with tips off |
| Who funds the platform | A fee on each gift | Optional donor tips, or a 3% fee |
| Paid tier | Pro, $150/month | Plus, from $29/month billed annually |
| Team members | 5 on Standard | Unlimited users |
The pick when you want a tip-free checkout and can live with a fee you can predict. Under $12,500 a month online, stay on Standard and skip Pro.
Neon CRM
Neon CRM is the move for teams that like Givebutter's forms but have outgrown its CRM. It is a full donor database: supporter profiles, reports and dashboards, automated workflows and grant tracking on the data side; campaigns, forms, peer-to-peer, recurring gifts and payment processing on the fundraising side; email, text messaging, stewardship journeys and a donor portal for communications. Unlike Givebutter, where workflows, texting and ready-made reports sit behind Plus, these are the core of the product.
The pricing is the other big difference. Neon CRM charges on your organization's revenue, not on contacts, and starts at $99 a month, with unlimited records, users, emails, forms, workflows and reports. Optional modules are a share of the CRM fee: +10% for Memberships and Volunteers, +20% for Events. At the entry price, Events alone brings the bill to $118.80 a month. That is more than Givebutter Plus at its first tier ($29 a month billed annually), but Givebutter Plus rises with your contact count, while Neon's bill rises with revenue.
Support by live chat, email and phone is included, and onboarding comes as packages up to full-service data migration. If accounting is your next pain, our nonprofit accounting software ranking covers that side.
- Priced on revenue, not on contacts
- Unlimited records, users, emails and forms
- Live chat, email and phone support included
- ✓Workflows and reports without an upgrade
- ✓Peer-to-peer and recurring gifts on every plan
- ✓Add-on prices stated as a percentage
- ✗$99 a month entry price for the CRM
- ✗Events, Memberships and Volunteers cost 10% to 20% more
- ✗Onboarding is a separate package
| Criterion | Neon CRM | Givebutter |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing unit | Organization revenue | Free; Plus by contacts |
| Entry price | $99/month | $0 (Plus from $29/month) |
| Workflows and texting | Included | Plus only |
| Phone support | Included | Plus only |
The pick when your CRM matters more than your donation form. If you only need forms and a contact list, Givebutter's free plan or Zeffy still does the job for less.
RallyUp
RallyUp is the alternative for organizations whose year turns around events rather than donation forms. It covers ticketing, online and in-person auctions, raffles and sweepstakes, A-Thons, Fund-a-Need, crowdfunding, storefronts and livestreaming, each as a component you add to a campaign. Givebutter does events and auctions too; RallyUp goes further on games of chance and caps its auction fee per item.
Its pricing choice is its strongest feature. On the Free plan, donors are asked for an optional tip and you never pay a platform fee, even if no donor tips. On the Flex plan, donors are not asked to tip and a platform fee is deducted instead: 2.9% for ticketing and storefronts, 4.9% for auctions, crowdfunding, A-Thons, Fund-a-Need and Paddle Raise+, 6.9% for raffles and sweepstakes. Donation pages and livestreaming carry no platform fee. The auction fee is capped at $100 per item, however high the winning bid. Processing goes through your own Stripe or PayPal account, at 1.9% to 2.9% plus $0.30 per transaction, and RallyUp keeps none of it.
There are no contracts, subscriptions, setup or minimum fees, and the plan you pick is locked once the campaign goes live, so you can run one gala on Flex and the next appeal on Free. Check the components first: live and silent auctions, Fund-a-Need, Paddle Raise+ and event balances exist only on Flex, so a gala with a live auction cannot run on Free. A custom domain is a one-time $99. For broader event logistics, see our nonprofit event management software ranking.
- Free or Flex pricing chosen per campaign
- Auction fee capped at $100 per item
- Raffles, sweepstakes and A-Thons built in
- ✓No contract, subscription or setup fee
- ✓Donation pages free on both plans
- ✓Processing paid straight to Stripe or PayPal
- ✗Raffles cost 6.9% on Flex
- ✗You must connect your own Stripe or PayPal
- ✗Plan is locked once a campaign goes live
| Criterion | RallyUp | Givebutter |
|---|---|---|
| Cost on a $100 ticket, no tips | $2.90 platform fee + processing | $3 platform fee + $3.20 processing |
| Who funds the platform | Tips (Free) or fee (Flex), per campaign | Tips or 3%, set per campaign; 3% on auto-charged auction items |
| Auctions | 4.9% capped at $100 per item | Included |
| Contract | None | None (Plus cancellable anytime) |
The pick for gala, auction and raffle season. For year-round online giving with a donor CRM, Zeffy or Donorbox fits better.
Little Green Light
Little Green Light, LGL for short, is not a fundraising page builder like Givebutter: it is a donor database for teams that want to manage relationships, not only collect money. Givebutter users usually land here when the free CRM feels thin for gift history, pledges, mailings and board reports, and they do not want a sales-quoted system.
The price follows the number of constituent records only. Up to 2,500 constituents, $45 a month on monthly billing; up to 5,000, $60; up to 10,000, $75; up to 50,000, $135; then $15 a month for each extra 10,000. Prepaying 12 months saves 10%: 2,500 constituents cost $486 a year, or $40.50 a month. Users are unlimited, there is no contract and no cancellation fee, and the first 30 days are free.
Online donations run through LGL forms, pay-as-you-go, starting at 2.2% + $0.30 per transaction paid to the payment processor, with no fee to LGL. Compared with Givebutter with tips off, that is 3% less per gift and 0.7% less processing. What LGL does not give you is the campaign-page polish, auctions or event check-in app of Givebutter. Many small teams keep a free fundraising tool for events and use LGL as the record of truth: Donorbox and RallyUp maintain their own integrations with LGL, and Givebutter gifts can flow in through a Zapier connection to Little Green Light. Our Bloomerang alternatives page compares it with other donor CRMs.
- $45 a month up to 2,500 constituents
- Unlimited users on every account
- No contract and no cancellation fee
- ✓No platform fee on LGL donation forms
- ✓Every feature in a single plan
- ✓30 days free before any charge
- ✗No auctions or event check-in app
- ✗Price rises with your record count
- ✗Campaign pages are simpler than Givebutter's
| Criterion | Little Green Light | Givebutter |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing unit | Constituent records | Free; Plus by contacts |
| Entry price | $45/month (2,500 records) | $0 (Plus from $29/month) |
| Platform fee on gifts | None | $0 with tips, 3% without |
| Users | Unlimited | Unlimited |
The pick when you need a real donor database on a small budget. If auctions and peer-to-peer pages drive your revenue, keep a fundraising tool next to it.
Bloomerang
Bloomerang is the one-vendor answer for a nonprofit that has outgrown free tools. Its Giving Platform bundles Bloomerang Fundraising, Bloomerang CRM and Bloomerang Volunteer, with unlimited users, and it is known for its focus on donor retention: engagement scores, data hygiene and stewardship tools that Givebutter only starts to cover with Plus.
The trade-off is the buying process. Bloomerang does not publish an amount: it offers annual pricing built for your nonprofit, on a quote, with a constituent-based model, so the bill grows with the number of supporters in your database. Its proposals include training and onboarding, with no add-ons for core features later, and it states that you own your data and can export it at any time. Coming from Givebutter, where the free plan has no subscription at all, that is a new annual budget line to plan for.
Choose it when your team has a development director, a donor base worth a dedicated retention strategy, and the budget for an annual contract. If you want a record-based CRM with a public price list, Little Green Light publishes its grid; if you are already weighing Bloomerang against others, see our full comparison of Bloomerang alternatives, and our nonprofit CRM pricing index for the market.
- Fundraising, CRM and volunteers in one platform
- Unlimited users
- Onboarding and training included in proposals
- ✓Strong donor retention focus
- ✓You own your data, with exports at any time
- ✓No surprise add-ons for core features
- ✗No public price, only an annual quote
- ✗Bill grows with your constituent count
- ✗An annual contract replaces Givebutter's free plan
| Criterion | Bloomerang | Givebutter |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing unit | Constituent records | Free; Plus by contacts |
| Entry price | Annual quote | $0 (Plus from $29/month) |
| Volunteer management | Bloomerang Volunteer | Not a dedicated module |
| Contract | Annual | None (Plus cancellable anytime) |
The pick when you want one vendor and a retention-focused CRM, and can sign an annual deal. On a tight budget, Neon CRM or Little Green Light gets you most of it for less.
6 Givebutter alternatives compared
Read the "Cost of one $100 card gift" column first. It shows what the nonprofit pays on a single online donation when donors leave nothing extra, the case Givebutter's tip model hides. On Givebutter, that cost is $0 with tips on and $6.20 with tips off. Prices are entry prices from each vendor's pricing page.
| Best for | Cost of one $100 card gift, no tip | Free plan | Team size | Visit | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Zeffy | Best fully free fundraising platform | $0, fees covered by Zeffy | 4.3/5 | $0 | ✓ | Small nonprofits | Visit → |
| 2 | Donorbox | Best donation forms with no tip prompt | $2.95 + processor fee | 4.3/5 | $0 + 2.95% fee | ✓ | Online donation programs | Visit → |
| 3 | Neon CRM | Best full donor CRM when Givebutter's CRM runs short | Processor fee, CRM from $99/mo | 4.3/5 | $99/mo | — | Growing development teams | Visit → |
| 4 | RallyUp | Best for auctions, raffles and event fundraising | Processing only on Free, $2.90 + processing on Flex tickets | 4.2/5 | $0 | ✓ | Events, auctions, raffles | Visit → |
| 5 | Little Green Light | Best budget donor database with no contract | 2.2% + $0.30 to processor, no LGL fee | 4.2/5 | $45/mo | — | Small nonprofits | Visit → |
| 6 | Bloomerang | Best all-in-one giving platform for established teams | Included in annual quote | 4.0/5 | Quote | — | Established mid-size nonprofits | Visit → |
Givebutter reference: free plan with optional donor tips, or 3% platform fee + 2.9% + 30¢ card processing with tips off; Plus from $29/month billed annually. DonorPerfect, GoFundMe Pro (formerly Classy), OneCause and Funraise are covered in the buyer's guide.
Is your tool missing from this page? Email us: hello@hackceleration.com
Which Givebutter alternative is right for you?
One $0 plan; Zeffy covers card and transaction fees.
You do not want donors to see any tip requestDonorbox2.95% platform fee on forms, no tip line, donors can cover fees.
Your team needs workflows, reports and textingNeon CRMFrom $99 a month, priced on revenue, with unlimited records.
Your revenue comes from galas, auctions and rafflesRallyUpFree or Flex chosen per campaign, auction fee capped at $100 an item.
You need a donor database under $100 a monthLittle Green Light$45 a month up to 2,500 constituents, no contract.
You want fundraising, CRM and volunteers from one vendorBloomerangGiving Platform on an annual quote, unlimited users.
How to choose a Givebutter alternative
Givebutter belongs to a category usually called online fundraising or donation software: tools that put a payment form, a campaign page or a ticket checkout in front of donors, collect the money through a card processor such as Stripe or PayPal, issue the receipt and store the donor in a contact list. Donor CRMs, by contrast, are built to manage the relationship after the gift: history, pledges, segments, tasks and reports. Givebutter sits between the two, which is why its alternatives come from both sides.
Every online gift carries up to three costs, and each tool assigns them differently. The processing fee goes to the card network and processor, usually around 2.2% to 2.9% plus 30 cents for a US nonprofit. The platform fee is the vendor's own cut, a percentage of the gift. A tip, or donor contribution, is an optional extra the donor pays to the vendor at checkout, which replaces the platform fee in models like Givebutter's, Zeffy's or RallyUp's Free plan. Then there is the subscription, a monthly or annual price for the software itself.
Before you compare features, ask each vendor four things: what a $100 card gift costs you with no tip and no fee coverage, whether the donor sees a tip request and can set it to zero easily, what the bill becomes at twice your current contact count, and how you take your donors and recurring gifts with you when you leave. Then run your last twelve months of online revenue through each model.
Pitfall 1: a 15% default tip can cost you the donor
Pitfall 2: an upgrade that lowers fees can cost more than it saves
Pitfall 3: raffles and auctions carry higher fees
Pitfall 4: monthly billing on Plus and add-ons adds up
What about DonorPerfect, GoFundMe Pro, OneCause and Funraise?
- Price one $100 card gift with no tip and no fee coverage
- Check how the donor removes a tip
- Run last year's online revenue through each fee model
- Ask for the price at twice your contact count
- Export contacts, transactions and recurring plans before you switch
- Tell recurring donors before their card moves to a new processor
Givebutter alternatives, the FAQ
Can donors remove the tip on Givebutter?
Yes, but it is not always obvious. Donors can edit or remove the suggested contribution at checkout, but one nonprofit admin reports that donors had to set a custom amount to 0 to remove it. Test your own form on a phone before a campaign, and mention in your appeal that the tip goes to Givebutter, not to you.What is the Givebutter Guarantee?
It is Givebutter's promise that, with tips enabled, your nonprofit keeps 100% of what it raises: when donors choose not to cover processing fees, Givebutter pays them. The guarantee does not apply when tips are off, which is when the 3% platform fee and standard processing come back. It also excludes card reader and terminal payments, DAFpay gifts and recurring plans that began before Givebutter's 2025 pricing change, and imported recurring plans are covered only once you edit them on a campaign with tips enabled.How long do Givebutter payouts take?
Direct deposits to a bank account or a debit card take 2 to 3 business days, and Givebutter charges no payout fee and sets no payout limit. Verified nonprofits can also turn on automated deposits. When you migrate, plan your last payout before closing campaigns so no funds sit in the old account.Does Givebutter Plus lower the platform fee?
No. Givebutter Plus has the same options for donor tipping, platform fees and payment processing as the free plan: you pay for workflows, reports, texting and QuickBooks sync, not for cheaper donations. If lower fees are the goal, a fee-based tool with paid tiers, such as Donorbox Pro, is the one that trades a subscription for a lower rate.Will I be charged for contacts on the free Givebutter CRM?
No. Givebutter states you will never be required to pay for contacts in the free CRM, nor to upgrade to Plus, whatever your contact count. Contact-based pricing applies only to Plus, and above your tier you pay for extra contacts in increments of 100.Does Donorbox charge anything in a month with no donations?
No. On the free Standard plan without add-ons, you only pay the platform fee and processing fee when a donation happens, so a month with no gifts costs nothing. Add-ons such as Text-to-Give or the Live Kiosk app are monthly subscriptions that renew automatically, so cancel them in quiet months.Which Givebutter alternative accepts crypto and stock donations?
Donorbox accepts cryptocurrency and stock gifts on its Pro plan, with a 3.95% total fee per transaction that includes both the platform and processing fee. Givebutter also lists DAF donations among its features; check your volume of non-cash gifts before paying $150 a month for Pro to unlock them.How do I move recurring donors off Givebutter?
Plan it as its own project, because card details stay with the old payment processor. Donorbox lists migration of recurring donors as a $195 flat-fee service, and Premium lists it among the extras you choose from. Elsewhere, export your recurring plans, email each recurring donor with a new link, and only cancel the old plans once the new ones are active.