AthenaHQ Alternatives

Six AI search visibility trackers that replace AthenaHQ, compared on what a month of AI answers really costs.

The best AthenaHQ alternative for most marketing teams is Peec AI: its Starter plan costs $95 a month and runs 4,500 AI answers, where AthenaHQ Starter costs $295 for 3,600. On a tight budget, Otterly.AI starts at $29 a month. If you already pay for an SEO suite, Semrush or SE Ranking add AI tracking to the tool you have. We compared six platforms on quotas, engines and the cost of each AI answer.

Romain CochardCEO of Hack'celeration
Updated 20266alternatives compared5criteria each2026pricing checked

The ranking is editorial: a sponsored placement is always flagged on its card, and no affiliate link changes a score.

The honest take

Why teams are leaving AthenaHQ

AthenaHQ is an AI search visibility platform, a category also called GEO (generative engine optimization). It asks AI assistants such as ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini or Google's AI Overviews the questions your buyers ask, records whether your brand appears and which sources the answer cites, then suggests or writes content to improve the result. Its free Essential plan covers 5 engines and its Starter plan 11. The product is broad. People leave because of how its plans are sized and priced.

A $295 jump from the free plan

AthenaHQ has two self-serve tiers: Essential, free, and Starter at $295 a month on monthly billing, or $245 a month billed annually. There is no plan in between. A team that outgrows the free credits goes straight to $3,540 a year on monthly billing, while Peec AI starts at $95 and Otterly.AI at $29.

Unlimited prompts, limited credits

Starter advertises unlimited topics and prompts, but it includes 3,600 credits a month and one credit is one AI response. One prompt checked daily on all 11 models uses about 341 credits a month, so 3,600 credits run roughly 10 prompts across every model. The real limit is the credit, not the prompt.

A high price per AI answer

Divide the plan fee by its answers: AthenaHQ Starter costs about 8 cents per AI response ($295 for 3,600). Peec AI Starter runs 4,500 answers for $95, about 2 cents each. If what you need is measurement, you pay four times more per data point at AthenaHQ.

Extra credits and API priced on request

API access and extra credits are optional add-ons billed on top of the Starter subscription, and their price is given only on request. A team that plugs AI visibility data into its own dashboards cannot know the full monthly bill before talking to sales.

Multi-region and SSO wait for Enterprise

Starter includes country-level support, but multi-region and multi-language tracking, SAML and OIDC SSO, persona targeting and the executive dashboard with Tableau, Power BI or Looker are listed under Enterprise, on custom pricing. Otterly.AI includes unlimited countries and languages on every plan, from $29.
1
Best all-round AthenaHQ replacement

Peec AI

4.4/5

Peec AI is an AI search visibility tracker. You give it the questions your buyers type into ChatGPT, Perplexity or Google AI Mode (it calls them prompts), it asks those questions every day on the models you pick, and it reports how often your brand appears, in which position, with which sentiment, and which websites the AI cited as sources. That is the same job AthenaHQ does in its tracking layer, minus the content agent that writes or rewrites pages for you.

The quota is stated in prompts and in answers. Starter costs $95 a month on monthly billing and $80 a month billed annually. It covers 50 prompts on 3 models of your choice, checked daily, which the pricing page turns into 4,500 AI answers a month, for 1 project and 1 country. Pro, at $245, raises that to 150 prompts, 13,500 answers, 2 projects and 3 countries; Advanced, at $495, to 350 prompts, 31,500 answers and 5 projects with a Looker Studio integration. Every plan has unlimited users and unlimited competitors. A fourth model on Starter is an add-on at $35 a month on monthly billing.

Next to AthenaHQ, the entry price is the story: $95 for 4,500 answers against $295 for 3,600 credits, where one AthenaHQ credit is one AI response. Peec's action layer is a gap analysis, recommended actions ranked by impact and an agent that runs on credits (500 a month on Starter) with pre-built skills for reports and diagnostics; AthenaHQ goes further into execution, with a content optimization agent and on-page and off-page actions. One limit to know before you pick Starter: API access to your data starts on Pro. Its data can also be queried from an AI assistant, as in our guide to the Peec AI integration with Claude. For the wider list of trackers, see our ranking of the best AI visibility tools for GEO, and our Peec AI alternatives to see what pushes its own users away.

Standout features
  • 4,500 AI answers a month for $95
  • Unlimited users on every plan
  • AI Shopping tracking per product (SKU)
+Pros
  • ✓Quota stated in prompts and in answers
  • ✓Annual billing cuts Starter to $80
  • ✓Shopify catalog import for product tracking
−Cons
  • ✗3 models only below Enterprise
  • ✗1 country on Starter
  • ✗No API access on Starter (from Pro)
Verdict
Take Peec AI if you mainly need to measure your AI visibility every day and the AthenaHQ price is what hurts. If you want software that also writes and fixes your pages, look at AthenaHQ's own Starter or at Scrunch.
See Peec AI plans → →
2
Cheapest way to start tracking

Otterly.AI

4.3/5

Otterly.AI tracks how ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Google AI Mode, Perplexity, Microsoft Copilot, Gemini and Claude talk about your brand. It reports brand mentions, sentiment, share of voice and the domains each engine cites, and adds a GEO audit that checks whether AI crawlers can read your site. It is the most budget-friendly tracker in this list, and its pricing page explains the quota down to the credit.

That quota is counted in credits. One credit is one prompt checked once on one AI engine, so a prompt tracked daily on one engine uses 31 credits a month. Lite costs $29 a month for 20 prompts and 2,000 credits on 3 of the 7 engines, with 1 workspace and 3 recommendations a week. Standard, at $189, gives 160 prompts and 15,000 credits, unlimited workspaces and API access; Premium, at $489, 535 prompts and 50,000 credits, with weekly tracking as an option. Annual billing takes 15% off. Every plan includes unlimited brands, competitors, team members, countries and languages, and the subscription can be cancelled from the account settings.

Next to AthenaHQ, Otterly is a monitoring tool with recommendations, not an execution platform: it tells you what to change, you change it. One detail matters for the budget: a Claude answer counts as 3 credits, every other engine as 1, so adding Claude to a Lite plan eats your credits three times faster. Lite also cannot buy extra credit packs: you move to Standard once 20 prompts are not enough.

Standout features
  • Paid plan from $29 a month
  • Unlimited seats, countries and languages
  • GEO audit of crawlability and content
+Pros
  • ✓Credit rules explained to the unit
  • ✓Free trial before paying
  • ✓Cancel any time from the account
−Cons
  • ✗Claude answers cost 3 credits each
  • ✗Lite has 1 workspace and no credit packs
  • ✗Weekly tracking only from Premium
Verdict
Take Otterly.AI if you want to start tracking AI answers this week for the price of a lunch per month. Teams that need more than 160 prompts should compare Standard with Peec AI Pro before they commit.
See Otterly.AI plans → →
3
Best if you already run Semrush

Semrush

4.2/5

Semrush is the large SEO suite, and its AI Visibility Toolkit adds AI search tracking to it. The toolkit shows how your brand appears in AI answers, which prompts mention you or your competitors, and runs AI search checks inside the Site Audit. The point of choosing it over AthenaHQ is not depth in AI tracking: it is having AI visibility, organic rankings, backlinks and site audits in the same reports.

The standalone toolkit costs $99 a month and includes 25 prompts for Prompt Tracking, AI search checks in Site Audit for up to 100 pages and 10 CSV exports a day. Add-ons are priced per unit: 50 more prompts for $60 a month, an extra domain for Brand Performance for $99 a month, and a license of $99 for each additional user who needs the toolkit in a corporate account. If you need the full suite, Semrush One bundles the SEO and AI Visibility toolkits: its SEO + AI Search Starter plan costs $199 a month, or $165.17 a month billed yearly, and raises Prompt Tracking to 50 prompts; Pro+ costs $299 a month with 100 prompts. The toolkit has no free trial, so the first month is paid.

Next to AthenaHQ, the quota is small: 25 prompts against AthenaHQ's unlimited prompts within 3,600 credits. The trap is seats: AthenaHQ includes unlimited seats on every plan, while each extra Semrush user of the toolkit is another $99. Read our full Semrush review, our Semrush vs Ahrefs comparison if you hesitate between the two suites, and, if Semrush itself is the problem, our list of Semrush alternatives.

Standout features
  • AI visibility next to SEO data
  • AI search checks in Site Audit
  • Add prompts in packs of 50
+Pros
  • ✓One login for SEO and GEO
  • ✓Monthly price of $99 for the toolkit
  • ✓50 prompts in Semrush One Starter
−Cons
  • ✗Only 25 prompts in the base toolkit
  • ✗$99 per extra user license
  • ✗No free trial on the toolkit
Verdict
Take Semrush if your team lives in it already and you need AI visibility as one more report. If AI search is your main channel, a dedicated tracker gives you more prompts per dollar.
See Semrush plans → →
4
Best value inside an SEO suite

SE Ranking

4.1/5

SE Ranking is an SEO platform for rank tracking, site audits and competitor research. Its AI visibility product, SE Visible, tracks how your brand appears on ChatGPT, Copilot, Google AI Overviews, AI Mode and Gemini, with no add-on per engine, in 42 countries and 9 languages. Every SE Ranking plan includes some SE Visible limits, which makes it the cheapest way in this list to get AI visibility data inside a full SEO suite.

Core costs $129 a month on monthly billing and $103.20 a month billed yearly, for 10 projects, 1 manager seat, 2,000 keywords tracked daily and 250,000 audited pages a month. On the AI side, you can monitor 25 prompts daily at no extra cost, and plans with more prompts start at 75 tracked prompts. The dedicated AI visibility plans start at $71 a month billed yearly, or $89 on monthly billing. Growth, at $279 a month ($223.20 yearly), brings 30 projects and 3 manager seats; an extra manager seat starts at $16. The 14-day free trial includes 20 AI prompts a day, enough to test your real prompt list.

Next to AthenaHQ, SE Visible is built to measure and find gaps (its Agents, in beta, turn them into tasks). Perplexity is not in its list of engines, and Claude is tracked only on the Agency and Enterprise plans. The data leaves the platform through the API, MCP, Make, n8n or Zapier; our guide to the SE Ranking integration with Make shows the modules. For a team whose AI budget is part of an SEO budget, it is the best ratio: 25 daily prompts on 5 engines, plus all the SEO tools, for less than half of AthenaHQ Starter. If SE Ranking is already your tool and you want out, read our SE Ranking alternatives; for more suites, our ranking of the best SEO tools.

Standout features
  • 25 daily AI prompts included in every plan
  • 5 AI engines with no engine add-on
  • Full SEO suite in the same login
+Pros
  • ✓Core costs $103.20 a month billed yearly
  • ✓14-day free trial with 20 AI prompts a day
  • ✓Free assisted migration on annual plans
−Cons
  • ✗Perplexity not listed among the engines
  • ✗1 manager seat on Core (extra seats from $16)
  • ✗Claude only on Agency and Enterprise plans
Verdict
Take SE Ranking if you want AI tracking and SEO tracking for one price and your buyers mostly use ChatGPT and Google's AI. If Perplexity or Claude drive your traffic, pick a dedicated tracker.
See SE Ranking plans → →
5
Closest to AthenaHQ on optimization

Scrunch

4.0/5

Scrunch is an AI search platform that tracks your visibility and then works on the content AI engines read. Beyond the monitoring dashboard, its plans count citation targets (the pages and sources you want AI to cite) and pages optimized each month. That makes it the closest product in this list to AthenaHQ's promise of tracking plus action, rather than tracking alone.

The entry plan, Core, costs $250 a month, with a monthly or yearly billing switch and a 7-day free trial. Core includes 15,000 AI responses a month collected daily, 10 citation targets, 10 pages optimized and 10 pages generated a month, for 1 brand, 5 seats and 5 competitors. It covers 8 models: ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Google AI Overviews, Google AI Mode, Microsoft Copilot, Grok and Meta AI; Claude is not on Core and comes only as an Enterprise add-on. Core also tracks any country, language and persona, where AthenaHQ keeps multi-region tracking for Enterprise. Enterprise is on quote, with unlimited citation targets, API access and SAML or OIDC single sign-on. Scrunch also runs a separate offer for agencies.

Next to AthenaHQ, the entry price is $45 lower than AthenaHQ Starter on monthly billing, and the trial lets you see real data on your brand before you pay. On volume, Core collects 15,000 responses a month against 3,600 on AthenaHQ Starter. What you give up is AthenaHQ's free Essential plan, its unlimited seats (Core has 5) and Claude tracking. Scrunch is the pick when you leave AthenaHQ for a better optimization workflow, not to save money.

Standout features
  • Tracking and page optimization in one plan
  • Citation targets you can steer
  • Agency offer separate from brands
+Pros
  • ✓7-day free trial
  • ✓15,000 AI responses a month on Core
  • ✓8 models including Grok and Meta AI
−Cons
  • ✗Entry plan at $250 a month
  • ✗5 seats and 1 brand on Core
  • ✗No Claude on Core
Verdict
Take Scrunch if you like AthenaHQ's mix of tracking and action and want a second opinion on the same job. If you only need numbers, Peec AI or Otterly.AI cost far less.
See Scrunch plans → →
6
Best for large enterprise programs

Profound

3.9/5

Profound is an enterprise AI visibility platform. It tracks how your brand shows up across answer engines, analyzes the sources they cite, and adds an AI Marketer that runs on credits to act on the findings. It tracks up to 10 answer engines: ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Mode, Gemini, DeepSeek, Claude, Google AI Overviews, Exa Search, Muse Spark and Qwen, with prompts checked daily.

Pricing changed in 2026: Profound retired its Starter and Growth plans for brands and now lists a single Enterprise plan on custom pricing. The $399 and $499 prices of those plans are no longer available for new subscriptions, so a comparison that still quotes them is out of date. Prompts, credits and engine choice are set in the contract, seats are unlimited, and when credits run out you choose between overage billing and a pause at the limit. There is no self-serve plan any more.

Next to AthenaHQ, Profound is a larger option, for teams that found AthenaHQ Starter too small for a multi-brand program. If price is your reason to leave AthenaHQ, skip it. To compare it with the others in detail, read our Profound alternatives.

Standout features
  • Up to 10 answer engines tracked
  • Daily prompt checks
  • Unlimited seats
+Pros
  • ✓Tracks DeepSeek, Exa, Muse Spark and Qwen
  • ✓Choice between overage and pause
  • ✓Built for multi-brand programs
−Cons
  • ✗Price only on quote
  • ✗No self-serve plan since 2026
  • ✗Sales cycle before any data
Verdict
Take Profound if you run AI visibility as an enterprise program with procurement and a large budget. Everyone else gets faster value from Peec AI or Otterly.AI.
See Profound → →
At a glance

6 AthenaHQ alternatives compared

Read the "Entry quota" column first. AI visibility tools count usage in different units (prompts, credits, answers, citation targets), so we wrote what the cheapest paid plan actually includes. For reference, AthenaHQ Starter includes 3,600 credits a month, one credit per AI response, for $295.

Best forEntry quotaFree planTeam sizeVisit
1Peec AIBest all-round AthenaHQ replacement50 prompts, 3 models, 4,500 answers a month4.4/5$95 monthly / $80 yearly—Unlimited usersVisit →
2Otterly.AICheapest way to start tracking20 prompts, 2,000 credits a month, 3 engines4.3/5$29 monthly—Unlimited seatsVisit →
3SemrushBest if you already run Semrush25 prompts in the AI Visibility Toolkit4.2/5$99 monthly—$99 per extra userVisit →
4SE RankingBest value inside an SEO suite25 daily prompts on 5 engines, with the SEO suite4.1/5$129 monthly / $103.20 yearly—1 manager seat on CoreVisit →
5ScrunchClosest to AthenaHQ on optimization15,000 responses, 10 citation targets, 8 models4.0/5$250 monthly—Brands and agenciesVisit →
6ProfoundBest for large enterprise programsCustom prompts, up to 10 engines3.9/5On quote—Enterprise, unlimited seatsVisit →

Yearly means the monthly price when billed annually; monthly means billed month to month. Prices in US dollars, excluding tax.

Is your tool missing from this page? Email us: hello@hackceleration.com

Reality check

Should you stay on AthenaHQ?

Stay on AthenaHQ if…

  • You use the content optimization agent and the on-page and off-page actions every week: Scrunch Core comes closest here, with 10 pages optimized and 10 generated a month, while Peec AI and Otterly.AI are built to measure and recommend.
  • You need 11 models on one plan: Peec AI Starter covers 3 and Otterly.AI Lite 3 of its 7 engines.
  • Your whole team logs in: AthenaHQ includes unlimited seats with role-based access, where Semrush charges $99 per extra toolkit user.
  • You sell on Shopify or Webflow and use the integrations included in Starter to tie AI visibility to your store or site.

Leave AthenaHQ if…

  • You mainly read the dashboard: Peec AI gives 4,500 answers a month for $95, against 3,600 for $295.
  • Your budget is under $100 a month: Otterly.AI Lite costs $29 and Semrush's toolkit $99.
  • You need several countries or languages without an Enterprise contract: Otterly.AI includes them on every plan.
  • You already pay for an SEO suite: SE Ranking includes 25 daily AI prompts in every plan.
Buyer's guide

How to choose an AthenaHQ alternative

AthenaHQ and every tool on this page belong to one category: AI search visibility, also sold as GEO (generative engine optimization) or AEO (answer engine optimization). The idea is the same as rank tracking in SEO, applied to AI assistants. Instead of checking your position on Google for a keyword, the software asks ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Claude or Google's AI Overviews a question your buyers ask, reads the answer, and records whether your brand is mentioned, in which position, in what tone, and which web pages the assistant cited as sources. Repeated every day or week over dozens of questions, those answers become a visibility score and a share of voice against your competitors. For the vocabulary, our GEO glossary defines each term.

The bill follows three units, and vendors do not use the same one. A prompt is one question you track, such as "best CRM for a small agency". A model or engine is one AI assistant that answers it. An answer, response or credit is one prompt asked once on one model. The number that decides the price is the number of answers: prompts × models × checks per month. Peec AI states it plainly (50 prompts × 3 models × daily = 4,500 answers on Starter); AthenaHQ and Otterly.AI sell credits, one credit per answer; Semrush and SE Ranking sell prompts. Convert every offer into answers per month before you compare.

Before you sign, ask each vendor five things: which engines are included and which cost extra; how often each prompt is checked; how many countries and languages a plan covers; how many seats are included; and whether you can export the raw answers, not only the scores. We also looked at Conductor, Airefs, AirOps, LLMrefs, Goodie and Ahrefs Brand Radar. Conductor is an enterprise SEO platform sold on demo, which does not solve the price problem that sends most people away from AthenaHQ. AirOps is a content workflow platform rather than a tracker. Airefs, LLMrefs and Goodie were named by fewer than three of the guides we read, and Ahrefs Brand Radar is covered in our AI visibility ranking. For tools that write and optimize content with AI, see our page on AI SEO tools.

Trap 1: unlimited prompts inside a credit cap

AthenaHQ Starter lists unlimited prompts, but 3,600 credits a month. One prompt checked daily on 11 models uses 11 × 31 = 341 credits, so the plan covers about 10 such prompts. Choose fewer models or check weekly if you want more prompts, and ask any vendor that says "unlimited" what the credit cap is.

Trap 2: Claude costs triple at Otterly.AI

Otterly.AI counts a Claude answer as 3 credits and every other engine as 1. On Lite, 20 prompts checked daily on 3 engines use 1,860 of the 2,000 credits; swap one engine for Claude and the same prompts need 3,100. Add Claude only if your buyers really use it.

Trap 3: the seat that costs a plan

Semrush charges $99 for each additional user license of the AI Visibility Toolkit, the price of the toolkit itself. A team of 4 pays $396 a month for 25 prompts. Peec AI, Otterly.AI and AthenaHQ include unlimited users. Count who needs to log in before you compare plan fees.

Tip: price each answer, not the plan

Divide the monthly fee by the answers it buys. AthenaHQ Starter: $295 for 3,600, about 8 cents. Peec AI Starter: $95 for 4,500, about 2 cents. Otterly.AI Lite: $29 for 2,000 credits, about 1.5 cents. Scrunch Core: $250 for 15,000 responses, about 1.7 cents. It is the fairest line to put in front of a finance team.

Test for free before you pay

AthenaHQ's free Essential plan includes 300 credits on 5 engines. Otterly.AI, Peec AI and SE Ranking (14 days, with 20 AI prompts a day) offer free trials, Scrunch a 7-day one; Semrush's AI Visibility Toolkit has none. SE Ranking also runs a free AI visibility check against up to 5 competitors, 5 checks a day. Load the same 20 prompts in every trial so the numbers compare.

Leaving AthenaHQ cleanly

Export your data first: Starter includes CSV export. Copy your list of prompts, topics and competitors, since it is the work that took longest to build. Run the new tool and AthenaHQ side by side for two weeks on the same prompts, compare the visibility scores, then cancel before your next billing date. On annual billing, plan the switch for the renewal.
  • Engines included and engines sold as add-ons
  • Prompts, models and checks per month, converted into answers
  • Countries and languages per plan
  • Seats included and price of an extra user
  • Export of raw answers and cited sources
  • Monthly and yearly price, and how to cancel
FAQ · 8 questions

AthenaHQ alternatives, the FAQ

  • Which AthenaHQ alternatives connect to Google Analytics?
    Peec AI does, on every plan. AthenaHQ Starter ties AI visibility to site traffic through GA4 and Search Console; Peec AI includes a Google Analytics integration and an AI referrals report on all its plans, and Scrunch Core reports AI referrals too. Use the referral report to see which assistant actually sends visits before you pay to track more engines.
  • Do unused AthenaHQ credits roll over?
    For one month: Starter includes a one-month credit rollover, so credits you do not spend move to the next month and no further. Otterly.AI works differently: its credits are slots assigned to a workspace, not used up, which you can reassign between projects at any time.
  • How many prompts do I need for reliable AI visibility data?
    Plan for 50 to 100 prompts per topic or market. Single AI answers vary from one day to the next, and in Otterly.AI's stability study, 100 prompts tracked daily for 30 days cut the variation in brand coverage by about 73% compared to 10 prompts.
  • Does weekly tracking save money?
    Yes, about seven times more prompts for the same credits. A weekly check runs about 4 times a month instead of about 31, so the same credit budget covers roughly 7 times more prompts. At Otterly.AI weekly tracking starts on Premium, and at Peec AI on Enterprise.
  • Do I need a ChatGPT or OpenAI subscription to use these tools?
    No, the tool runs the queries itself. Otterly.AI states that you do not need any additional OpenAI subscription, and SE Ranking checks ChatGPT, AI Overviews, AI Mode and Gemini the way a real user sees them and records the answer. The cost of querying each engine is part of the credits or answers you pay for.
  • Can AI visibility tools track ads inside ChatGPT?
    Some can. Otterly.AI lists ChatGPT Ads tracking on its plans, and Peec AI includes an Ads library showing the prompts where AI answers carry a sponsored placement and which advertisers appear. Use it to see whether a competitor buys the visibility you are trying to earn.
  • Can I track how AI recommends my products, not only my brand?
    Yes, at Peec AI: its AI Shopping module imports your catalog from Shopify or a CSV and reports visibility, position and win rate per product (SKU). On AthenaHQ, the Shopify integration comes with Starter. Track your best sellers first, not the whole catalog.
  • Which AI engines matter most to track?
    Start with ChatGPT and Google's AI Overviews and AI Mode, then add the engine your buyers use. Each engine multiplies your answer count: on Peec AI Starter, a fourth model costs $35 a month on monthly billing, so add Perplexity or Gemini only once your data shows they matter. For Claude, check the plan first: Peec AI lists it on Enterprise, SE Ranking on Agency and Enterprise, and Otterly.AI counts each Claude answer as 3 credits.
Hack'celeration Lab

Get the next software breakdown in your inbox

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.