Little Green Light Alternatives
Five Little Green Light alternatives for small nonprofits, compared on what you pay per record, per gift and per user, and on what you gain by moving.
Little Green Light is a cheap, record-priced donor database: $45 a month up to 2,500 constituents, or $486 a year prepaid. Most nonprofits that look for an alternative want built-in fundraising pages, automation or a bigger platform, not a lower bill. Our picks are Donorbox if online giving is the gap, Neon CRM if you need events, memberships and volunteers in one system, and Givebutter if you want a free CRM with campaigns attached. Keela and DonorDock cost more and add automation and coaching. We compared all five on price per record, fees per gift, users included and the work a migration takes.
The ranking is editorial: a sponsored placement is always flagged on its card, and no affiliate link changes a score.
Why nonprofits leave Little Green Light
Little Green Light, or LGL, is a web-based donor database for small and mid-size nonprofits. You store constituents, record gifts, send thank-you letters and tax receipts, and run the reports a board asks for. Its price depends on one thing only, the number of constituent records in your account, and every account gets every feature. That model makes it one of the cheapest donor CRMs you can buy. People rarely leave it for price. They leave it when the database is no longer the center of their fundraising and they need the giving pages, the automation or the event tools around it.
The price climbs with records, not with features
Emails are plain by design
Forms work, but they are basic
The interface shows its age
Gift entry depends on your integrations
Complex setups need outside help
Little Green Light alternatives compared
The five alternatives side by side, with the price each vendor publishes. Each tool gets five sub-scores out of 5, and its score is their simple average. Ease of use measures setup and daily work for a small team, Value for money what a nonprofit with a few thousand records pays in a year, fees included, Features and depth the donor, giving and event tools, Customer support and assistance the help included in the entry price, Available integrations accounting, email and payment links. The last column says what each tool does that LGL leaves to another product.
| Best for | Edge over Little Green Light | Free plan | Team size | Visit | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Donorbox | Best when online giving is the gap | Fundraising pages and peer-to-peer built in | 4.3/5 | Standard $0 with a 2.95% to 3.95% platform fee per gift; Pro $150/month with 1.75% to 2% | ✓ | Small to mid-size | Visit → |
| 2 | Neon CRM | Best all-in-one step up from LGL | Events, memberships, volunteers in one record | 4.3/5 | From $99/month, set by your revenue; Memberships and Volunteers +10%, Events +20% of the CRM fee | — | Mid-size | Visit → |
| 3 | Givebutter | Best free CRM with campaigns attached | Free CRM and campaigns, $0 a month | 4.1/5 | Free plan $0; Givebutter Plus from $29/month billed annually ($348/year) or $33.80 on monthly billing | ✓ | Small and volunteer-run | Visit → |
| 4 | Keela | Best for guided fundraising and automation | Automation that plans the next ask | 4.0/5 | From $164/month billed annually or $190 billed monthly, up to 1,000 contacts; $243 annually from 1,001 to 2,500 | — | Small teams | Visit → |
| 5 | DonorDock | Best for done-with-you onboarding | Email, texting and automation in one plan | 3.8/5 | One plan at $500/month billed annually, plus a one-time $3,800 premium onboarding; unlimited contacts | — | Small to mid-size | Visit → |
Is your tool missing from this page? Email us: hello@hackceleration.com
Donorbox
Donorbox started as a donation form and grew into a fundraising platform with its own donor CRM. Where LGL treats online giving as one feature of a database, Donorbox puts it at the center: donation forms and pages, quick one-click giving, crowdfunding, peer-to-peer supporter pages, event ticketing and memberships, all feeding the same donor records. The CRM is included on every plan, with static and dynamic lists and lifetime value per donor, so a small team can segment donors without exporting to a spreadsheet.
The pricing model is the opposite of LGL's. Standard costs nothing a month and charges a platform fee on each gift: 2.95% on forms, pages and crowdfunding, 3.95% on ticketing, memberships and peer-to-peer pages, plus card processing from 2.2% plus 30 cents at US nonprofit rates. Pro costs $150 a month and lowers the platform fee to between 1.75% and 2%, adds Zapier and API access, and raises the team from 5 to 10 members. Donors can be asked to cover the fees at checkout.
The limit is that a fee model punishes success. On $50,000 of online gifts a year, Standard's 2.95% is $1,475 in platform fees if donors do not cover them, three times LGL's prepaid year. It is also a fundraising tool first: gift entry for checks, grant tracking and major-gift task series are deeper in a classic donor database. Many teams solve this by keeping LGL and adding Donorbox, since Donorbox maintains its own integration with LGL.
- Forms, crowdfunding, peer-to-peer, tickets and memberships
- Donor CRM with dynamic lists on every plan
- Integration with LGL if you keep both
- ✓$0 a month on Standard
- ✓Donors can cover fees at checkout
- ✓Pro adds Zapier and API access
- ✗2.95% to 3.95% platform fee on every gift on Standard
- ✗Standard team capped at 5 members
- ✗Offline gift entry is thinner than LGL's
| Criterion | Donorbox | Little Green Light |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing unit | Fee per gift, or $150/month on Pro | Records in the database |
| Online giving | Core of the product | Basic forms via Stripe or PayPal |
| Team size | 5 on Standard, 10 on Pro | No per-user charge |
Pick Donorbox if most of your money now arrives online and LGL's forms hold you back. Take Neon CRM instead if you raise more than about $150,000 a year online, when a flat subscription beats any percentage, or stay on LGL and plug Donorbox in if the database itself still suits you.
Neon CRM
Neon CRM, from Neon One, is the usual next step for a nonprofit that has outgrown a simple donor database. It covers what LGL does, donor records, gifts, receipts and reports, and adds three modules sold as a share of the core fee: Memberships and Volunteers at 10% each, Events at 20%. With them you sell memberships and renew them, schedule volunteer shifts, as dedicated volunteer management software does, and sell tickets, all against the same constituent record. Neon Pay, its own payment processing, keeps online gifts in the same system.
Its price is set by your revenue, not by your record count, which is the key difference from LGL. The CRM starts at $99 a month and includes unlimited contacts, users, emails and reports. A nonprofit with a long list but a modest budget can pay less per record than on LGL's upper tiers; one with a large budget but a short list pays more. Live chat, email and phone support come free, and Neon sells onboarding packages that run from guided self-service to full-service data migration.
The limit is the bill once the modules stack. At the $99 entry price, adding Events alone takes you to $118.80 a month, and all three modules to $138.60, roughly three times LGL's prepaid rate before any onboarding package. The exact price comes from a downloadable pricing guide and a demo, so ask for onboarding and Neon Pay rates in writing at the same time.
- Revenue-based price with unlimited contacts
- Events, memberships and volunteers as modules
- Onboarding with full data migration available
- ✓Unlimited users, emails and reports
- ✓Free live chat, email and phone support
- ✓Payments, events and members in one record
- ✗$99 a month entry, before modules
- ✗Events module adds 20% of the CRM fee
- ✗Onboarding sold as separate packages
| Criterion | Neon CRM | Little Green Light |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing unit | Your annual revenue | Records in the database |
| Events | Ticketing module, +20% | Invitee and attendee tracking |
| Onboarding | Paid packages up to full migration | Self-service plus consultants |
Pick Neon CRM if LGL plus three side tools is now your stack, and one vendor for donors, members, volunteers and tickets is worth about three times the subscription. Take Givebutter instead if you need campaigns but not membership renewals, or Keela if the gap is fundraising automation rather than modules.
Givebutter
Givebutter gives away what LGL charges for: a donor CRM with unlimited users and contacts, email blasts and fundraising campaigns, on a plan that costs nothing a month. Campaigns cover donation forms, event tickets, auctions, peer-to-peer and text-to-give, and each gift lands in the contact record. Support is free for everyone, by live chat and email around the clock.
The free plan is funded by tips. When tips are on, donors are invited to add a tip at checkout, and the nonprofit pays no platform fee and no processing fee. When you switch tips off, a flat 3% platform fee applies, plus processing at 2.9% plus 30 cents per card gift or 1.9% plus 30 cents for ACH. Givebutter Plus, the paid layer, adds automated workflows, task management, reporting, texting, video messages, discounted direct mail, a QuickBooks Online integration and phone support, from $29 a month billed annually for the smallest contact tier, or $33.80 billed month to month. Plus can be tried for 30 days without commitment, which is the cheap way to test its workflows on your own donor list.
The limit is that the bill moves to your donors. A tip prompt at checkout is a cost some boards will not accept, and turning it off brings back fees that LGL does not charge. Plus is also priced by contacts, so the record discipline you learned on LGL still matters. Gift entry for checks and stock and grant tracking are lighter than in a dedicated donor database.
- Free CRM with unlimited users and contacts
- Forms, tickets, auctions, peer-to-peer in one place
- 24/7 chat and email support on the free plan
- ✓$0 a month, no time limit
- ✓No platform or processing fee while tips are on
- ✓Plus adds workflows and QuickBooks Online
- ✗Donors see a tip prompt at checkout
- ✗3% platform fee if you turn tips off
- ✗Plus is priced by contact count
| Criterion | Givebutter | Little Green Light |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly fee | $0, or Plus from $29 | From $45 |
| Fees per gift | Tips, or 3% plus processing | Processor fees only |
| Campaign pages | Built in | Basic forms |
Pick Givebutter if your nonprofit is small, raises most of its money in campaigns and events, and is fine with donor tips. Stay on LGL or take Neon CRM instead if your board wants no tip prompt and a donor database built for major gifts and grants.
Keela
Keela is a donor CRM built for small fundraising teams that want guidance as much as storage. Next to donor records, gifts and receipts, it adds donation forms and campaign pages, email marketing, and automation that moves donors through follow-up steps. Its pitch is that the software does part of a fundraiser's thinking: it surfaces the donors worth contacting and the tasks to do this week. Donations run through PayPal or Stripe at their nonprofit rate of 2.2% plus 30 cents, with no extra Keela fee per gift.
Keela is priced by contacts, like LGL, but on a very different scale. Up to 1,000 contacts, plans start at $164 a month billed annually or $190 month to month. From 1,001 to 2,500 contacts, they start at $243 annually or $259 monthly, and from 2,501 to 5,000 at $316 or $357. Personal email support runs from 9am to 5pm Pacific time, and Premium Care, with live chat, scheduled phone support and monthly training, starts at $200 a month on top. Data is stored in the United States, Canada or Australia depending on where your nonprofit is based.
The limit is plain: for the same 2,500 records, Keela's entry plan is $2,916 a year billed annually against $486 on LGL. You pay that difference for automation, built-in campaigns and coaching-style prompts. A team that will not use them is better off on LGL.
- Automation that suggests whom to contact next
- Forms, campaigns and email marketing built in
- Data stored in the US, Canada or Australia
- ✓No Keela fee on top of processor rates
- ✓Monthly or annual billing on every tier
- ✓Optional Premium Care with phone support and training
- ✗$164 a month for only 1,000 contacts on annual billing
- ✗Phone support costs from $200 a month extra
- ✗About six times LGL's price at 2,500 records
| Criterion | Keela | Little Green Light |
|---|---|---|
| Price at 2,500 records | $243/month billed annually | $40.50/month billed annually |
| Automation | Built-in donor journeys | Task series and scheduled reports |
| Support | Email 9 to 5 PT; phone extra | Included for every account |
Pick Keela if a small team needs the CRM to plan its fundraising and will use the automation every week. Take Givebutter instead if campaigns are what you need at no monthly cost, or stay on LGL if what you need is a clean database.
DonorDock
DonorDock sells a single plan, called One, that bundles a donor CRM with the outreach tools a small team usually buys separately. It includes unlimited contacts, 5 users, 10,000 emails and 1,000 text credits a month, and 10 automations, with donation pages on a 2% platform fee. The CRM suggests outreach tasks so a fundraiser knows whom to thank or call next. DonorDock states no long-term contracts and no hidden fees, and backs the plan with a 90-day money-back guarantee.
The plan costs $500 a month billed annually, plus a one-time premium onboarding of $3,800. Extra users cost $40 a month each, another 10,000 emails $45, another 1,000 text credits $19, and 5 more automations $60 a month. Contacts are unlimited, so the record count that drives LGL's price stops mattering. The onboarding fee buys a guided setup, which is what a team leaving a home-grown LGL configuration often needs.
The limit is the first-year bill: $6,000 for the subscription plus $3,800 of onboarding is $9,800, about twenty times LGL's prepaid year at 2,500 records. DonorDock makes sense when its bundled email, texting and automation replace other paid tools, not when it replaces LGL alone.
- Unlimited contacts on a single plan
- Email, texting and automation included
- Outreach task suggestions for fundraisers
- ✓One price, no tiers to outgrow
- ✓90-day money-back guarantee
- ✓Guided onboarding included in the setup fee
- ✗$9,800 in the first year with onboarding
- ✗Only 5 users before $40 a month each
- ✗2% platform fee on its donation pages
| Criterion | DonorDock | Little Green Light |
|---|---|---|
| First-year cost | $9,800 with onboarding | $486 prepaid at 2,500 records |
| Users | 5 included, then $40/month each | No per-user charge |
| Texting | 1,000 credits a month included | Not part of the plan |
Pick DonorDock if you will replace LGL plus an email tool, a texting tool and an automation tool, and want a vendor to run the setup. Take Neon CRM instead if events and memberships matter more than outreach, or Keela if you want automation at a lower first-year cost.
Which Little Green Light alternative for which case
Forms, crowdfunding and peer-to-peer, $0 a month on Standard.
You sell memberships, tickets and volunteer shiftsNeon CRMThree modules on one record, from $99 a month plus 10% or 20% each.
You have no budget for software at allGivebutterFree CRM and campaigns, funded by optional donor tips.
Your team needs to know whom to ask nextKeelaAutomation and prompts, from $164 a month billed annually.
You want email, texting and automation in one billDonorDockOne plan at $500 a month billed annually, unlimited contacts.
You like LGL but need better giving pagesKeep LGL and add DonorboxDonorbox maintains its own integration with LGL.
How to choose a Little Green Light alternative
What a donor CRM does. A donor CRM, also called donor management software, is the database where a nonprofit keeps everyone who gives it money or time. Each person or organization is a constituent record. Gifts, pledges, event attendance, volunteer hours and every letter or call are attached to that record. From there the software produces what a development office needs every week: thank-you letters and tax receipts, lists for the next appeal, and reports such as LYBUNT and SYBUNT, the donors who gave last year or some year but not this one. LGL does this job well, and our nonprofit CRM ranking lists the wider field. The tools on this page do it too, then add what LGL leaves to other products: giving pages, ticketing, automation or texting.
How the money side works. There are two layers on every online gift. The payment processor, Stripe or PayPal for most of these tools, takes a card fee, around 2.2% plus 30 cents at US nonprofit rates. The platform may take a second fee on top. LGL takes none; Donorbox Standard takes 2.95%; Givebutter takes none while donor tips are on and 3% when they are off. A subscription and a platform fee are two ways to charge for the same thing, so compare them on your own giving. Our online fundraising software ranking goes deeper on the giving side.
Learn each pricing unit before you compare. LGL and Givebutter Plus price by records or contacts, Keela by contacts in bands, Neon CRM by your annual revenue, DonorDock by a flat plan with user and email limits, and Donorbox by a share of each gift. A constituent is any record in the database, not only a donor: volunteers, event guests and newsletter sign-ups all count. A user is a staff login, which LGL and Neon CRM do not charge for and DonorDock includes five of, then bills at $40 a month each. Ask each vendor which of these units will move first at your size.
What to require before you sign. First, a full export of your current data, with gifts, notes and custom fields, and a sample import into the new tool's trial. Second, a plan for recurring donors: card tokens sit with the processor, so ask whether the new vendor can take them over. Donorbox charges a $195 flat fee to migrate recurring donors. Third, the written price at your record count or revenue in two years, not today. Fourth, the support you get on the entry plan, since several vendors sell phone support separately.
Three traps the comparison sites miss. Several guides say LGL has no online donation forms, no emailing and no memberships. Its own feature list includes all three, so check whether the gap you want to fix is a missing feature or a setting you never turned on. Second, a free plan with a per-gift fee is not free past a certain volume: on Donorbox, Pro at $150 a month beats Standard once you raise more than about $150,000 a year online, because the fee drops by roughly 1.2 points. Third, clean the database before you migrate. Contact-priced tools such as Keela and Givebutter Plus charge for every lapsed record you carry over, and merging duplicates first can drop you a pricing band.
Where to look next. If your shortlist includes the tools we cited but did not rank, our Bloomerang alternatives, DonorPerfect alternatives and Givebutter alternatives pages compare their nearest rivals. Bloomerang, DonorPerfect and Virtuous sell on quotes only, with no amount on their pricing pages, which is why they are not in this ranking.
Little Green Light alternatives: FAQ
Can I use Donorbox with Little Green Light?
Yes. Donorbox builds and maintains its own integration with LGL, so online gifts taken on Donorbox forms can flow into your LGL records. It is a common way to keep LGL's database and get stronger campaign pages, and LGL also lists Zapier connections for Givebutter, Give Lively, Fundraise Up and Square.Can a UK or European charity use Little Green Light?
No. Little Green Light tells organizations in the EU, the UK and Switzerland that it does not offer its software in their region, so a charity there has to start with another tool. Of the five on this page, Donorbox serves organizations in 96+ countries, while Keela stores data only in the United States, Canada or Australia, depending on where the nonprofit is based.How many records can a Little Green Light account hold?
Up to 200,000 constituent records. Past 50,000, each extra block of 10,000 adds $15 a month, so a full account costs $360 a month on monthly billing. A nonprofit that size usually looks at revenue-priced tools such as Neon CRM instead.Does Little Green Light have a free trial?
Yes, 30 days with all features and unlimited users, and no credit card. LGL does not charge a subscription for the first 30 days even if you subscribe during that time, so you can import a real export from your current tool before paying.How do I get my data out of Little Green Light if I leave?
LGL lets you export your data with no penalty or fee when you close your account, and there is no cancellation fee or contract. Export constituents, gifts and notes separately, and keep a copy of your custom field list, since the new tool will need matching fields before import.Does Little Green Light work with QuickBooks?
Yes. QuickBooks Online is one of the integrations LGL builds and maintains itself, alongside Mailchimp, Constant Contact, Stripe and PayPal. If accounting sync, or a move to proper nonprofit accounting software, is the reason you look elsewhere, check the QuickBooks Online settings first; Givebutter offers its own QuickBooks Online link only on the paid Plus plan.Can Little Green Light do wealth screening?
Yes, through integrations. LGL connects to DonorSearch and WealthEngine, two prospect research services, which add giving capacity and philanthropic history to your records. The screening itself is billed by those providers, not by LGL.Is there a free alternative to Little Green Light?
Yes. Zeffy is $0 and always free: on $50,000 raised, it says you keep the full $50,000, because optional donor tips fund it instead of fees. It is a fundraising platform with donor records rather than a full donor database, so check its reports before moving your major-gift work there.